Tuesday, November 25, 2008

Imagining India by Nandan Nilekani

Hi,

Have been following the launch of Nandan's book and have added to his blogsite. The same is being re-produced here. I am sure all of you also have some views to contribute on this.

------------------------------------

Indeed a very timely publication, coming in at a time when we are witnessing so many tensions on our social fabric. I haven’t read your book as yet, however have been following the release.

The concept of coming up with a set of idea is a great thought. It defintely encourages debate. The next step is to “action” this. And that is where the challenge lies in India. In our constitution we encourage plurality, which also is the essence of having a lively thriving democracy, however in order to take action once need a path, a direction. Unfortunately plurality does not provide “a path”, it provides “many paths”, and if one takes the option of “many paths”, it is wasteful and in-efficient.

From “plurality” to move to a situation of “Universal Choice”, we need strong individuals who can carry people together and hone the differences towards this universal choice. Mahatma Gandhi did it, even Pandit Nehru. However in today’s context it seems difficult to have such an individual emerge who could assimilate so many divergent views.

Even emergency situations can bridge this process from “Plurality to Universal Choice”, as you have mentioned happened in 1991. The question that begs an answer is do we wait for these emergencies to happen before we act?

One can say that let the Market drive this process. English as the main business language, has also been catalysed by Market demand. Market being the primary driver can be a matter of concern and greater debate.

------------------------------

I would highly appreciate if you could particpate and let me know your views on the above comments.

Thanks and regards.

Prodipto

No comments: